Sherlock: annotated disassembly

The case

The proof of the sale location needs the burning note examined before it burns to ashes (about 10:24am on Wednesday); the cure is DROP then a plain TAKE (fact 'The burning note...').

The solution, as the game stores it (9965). Say a statement to Inspector Lestrade (SAY TO LESTRADE "MRS BROWN KILLED HERSELF"); if all its evidence holds it is proven and its routine runs, otherwise it waits and is proven later, as soon as the evidence is complete (BC46). Evidence is "seen" (the player has seen both things), "examined" (has examined both), or a marker that only the code named can set. Proven or not, the statements decide the endings (9EA2, 9E85).

MRS BROWN KILLED HERSELF refused without its evidence and accepted with it; the Major's two statements proven together once his confession marker is set; TRICIA FENDER KILLED MRS JONES only ever waiting.

Markers set by shared actions 3 and 22 come from Tricia Fender's and Mrs Jones's own action lists, which are used when that person is the one acting (C933). Tricia Fender is Mrs Jones in disguise. Ask her about the bloodstained clothes while they are in the room (SAY TO TRICIA FENDER "TELL ME ABOUT BLOODSTAINED CLOTHES") and shared action 3 sets 998F and turns her actor-table entry into thing 95, Mrs Jones (E03A): "Oh my god, you found out, I am really Mrs Jones." Now Mrs Jones is an actor, and SAY TO MRS JONES "TELL ME ABOUT YOUR ALIBI" (or WHAT HAPPENED) runs shared action 22 and sets 9993.

What the proofs are for. Proving PHIPPS HAS PLANS and THE SALE LOCATION IS OLD MILL ROAD sends Lestrade to Old Mill Road in the police cab (E7E7). Phipps waits there on Wednesday from 12:10 until about 3:20pm and bolts if you turn up after 3pm; he then makes his way to platform one at Victoria (EE2B), and if you are there with Watson and Lestrade when he walks in, you win. If the statements are not proven, the papers end the game at 10am on Thursday (9EA2). See How the game is won.

RecordStatementEvidenceWhen proven
9965MAJOR PERCIVAL FFOULKES IS INNOCENT
  • 996B: the statement MAJOR PERCIVAL FFOULKES VISITED OPIUM DEN, proven in its own right (tell it to Lestrade); its evidence follows
  • 996F: a marker - set by the Major's confession in the opium den (F103)
9A3D: "VERY GOOD HOLMES, I SHALL RETURN TO LEATHER HEAD TOMORROW TO HAVE ANOTHER LOOK AROUND." - sets $9E88, so Lestrade will not arrest the Major (9E85)
9973MRS BROWN KILLED HERSELF
  • 9979: female corpse and sandstone bridge examined
  • 997D: large rock and large rock seen
9A4B: "SO MRS BROWN KILLED HERSELF, EXCELLENT HOLMES, ANOTHER BRILLIANT CONCLUSION."
9981MRS JONES KILLED TRICIA FENDER
  • 9987: body and bookcase examined
  • 998B: bloodstained clothes and bloodstained clothes examined
  • 998F: a marker - set by E1CB in shared action 3, which Tricia Fender performs when asked to tell about the bloodstained clothes away from them
HE CALLS FOR A CONSTABLE WHO LEADS THE VERY DISTRESSED MRS JONES OUT OF THE ROOM INTO THE DEPTHS OF SCOTLAND YARD." - Mrs Jones is led away (moved off stage)
9997PHIPPS HAS PLANS
  • 999D: unfinished note and folder examined
  • 99A1: letters and ripped coded baker note examined
  • 99A5: torn coded ?0f8 note and torn coded ?0f8 note examined
9A13: "VERY GOOD HOLMES, BASIL WILL LIKELY TRY TO SELL THEM, WE MUST FIND WHERE THE SALE LOCATION IS." - only if both murders are already proven; otherwise it is un-proven again
99A9SALE LOCATION IS OLD MILL ROAD
  • 99AF: a marker - set by proving PHIPPS HAS PLANS (9A13)
  • 99B3: burning note and burning note examined
  • 99B7: a marker - already set at the start; cleared when the burning note burns (9CA2)
99FC: "RIGHT THEN HOLMES WE MUST HURRY IF WE ARE TO CATCH THEM."
99BBTRICIA FENDER KILLED MRS BROWN
  • 99C1: a marker - nothing sets it, so this can never be proven
-
99C5TRICIA FENDER KILLED MRS JONES
  • 99CB: a marker - nothing sets it, so this can never be proven
-
99CFPHIPPS KILLED MRS BROWN
  • 99D5: a marker - nothing sets it, so this can never be proven
-
99D9PHIPPS KILLED MRS JONES
  • 99DF: a marker - nothing sets it, so this can never be proven
-
99E3TRICIA FENDER HAD PLANS
  • 99E9: bank account ?01d book and note examined
  • 99ED: unfinished note and folder examined
99F1TRICIA FENDER BLACKMAILED MRS BROWN
  • 99F7: a marker - set by proving TRICIA FENDER HAD PLANS (9A05)